I'd read and heard mixed reviews about this service, but I really could use a wardrobe update. This idea sounded helpful and fun, and I was ridiculously curious. So for $20, I took the plunge. I registered, thoughtfully answered the questionnaire, and I even created a Pinterest board of "Clothing I'd Wear" like Stitch Fix recommends because that's the best way for a stylist to visually understand what kinds of items you'd like or what you'd be comfortable wearing. All in all, it took me about three hours to get set up, but I'm not tech savvy and had to figure out how to use Pinterest; that was a time suck for me. (Those who are familiar with Pinterest would probably be ready to go in an hour.) I submitted my account and anxiously waited about two weeks for my first Fix to arrive.
It arrived a day earlier than scheduled, so that was a fabulous surprise from the start! I placed the box on my bed and, like a dork, was afraid to open it. I didn't want to be disappointed. Over those two weeks, I'd built it up in my head that this was going to be the best thing ever: "A fashion professional will dress me. They know what's up. They know what I need and what will make me look good." But then the doubt crept in after a horrible shopping trip to the mall a few days prior in which I was shopping for a dress for my brother-in-law's wedding. Nothing fit me right. No styles caught my eye. The prints were ugly. The cuts were not flattering. "It's hopeless! I'm going to get my package and it's all going to be like this stuff that does nothing for me!"
So there it sat. And there I stared at it.
Until I said, "Get a hold of yourself. It's just clothes!"
Then I started to unwrap the bundle. My heart kind of sank when I saw the small stripes through the tissue paper (I'm not always into tiny horizontal stripes), but then I saw the dress and the pants and the plaid and the cute sweater, and I realized how this was all fitting together.
And I was so pleased.
Forgive the photos. I am obviously not in the habit of taking selfies. Also, my olive green walls and plaid comforter aren't the best backdrops. Next month, I promise to have Elizabeth practice her photography skills. Here's what I received in my first Fix:
Item #1: Pixley Greenich Striped Knit Top, $48
Item #2: Kut from the Kloth Siena Cropped Pant, $58
The top didn't impress me at first glance, but the faux leather elbow patches and accents at the hips made it more than just another navy and white striped knit top. The fit and cut were really nice. Also, the fabric is heavier than the average knit and seems like it will last. Kept!
Though a brighter shade than I normally wear on the bottom, these pants fit great. The goal of this project is to update my wardrobe and wear more put-together outfits. When the shopping is placed in the hands of a trained professional, I gotta trust. Now if she had sent animal prints, we'd need to talk. But dark pink pants aren't that far outside of my comfort zone to sound any fashion alarms. Kept!
Item #3: Napean Sea Road Bellucci One Pocket Top, $58
I'm big on plaid (see comforter), and these colors are completely me. I loved this shirt the moment I saw it. There was no question I was going to buy this. If I sent everything else back, I'd gladly pay full price (minus my $20 stylist fee) for just this one piece. However, right before I checked out online I looked at the washing instructions on everything and noticed this item is dry clean only. I never go to the dry cleaners. I don't even know where the closest one is or how much it costs. Ever so dramatically, loud "noooooooooos" and "whyyyyyyyyys" went through my head. I looked at the material--100% rayon. Then I Googled "washing rayon" and realized that one absolutely should not put this shirt in the wash because it will be ruined through tearing or shrinking or bleeding colors. Even Martha Stewart said I had better not. But I really liked it. And when I looked through the rest of the mail later and saw this, I knew that everything would be okay.
I can dry clean at home? Sweet. Kept!
Item #4: Gilli Trista Faux Warp Jersey Dress, $68
Only a few days prior, I was at the mall trying on nearly every dress in the dress departments at both Macy's and Dilliard's. It was torturous, almost as bad as bathing suit shopping. How in the world my stylist knew I needed a dress to attend a wedding next month is beyond me, but she sent this dress and the angels sang from the heavens. It's more clingy than I prefer, but the print is very forgiving in the hips and the fit on top is perfect. Kept!
Item #5: Emily Rose Macy Open Cardigan, $58
Well this sweater goes with just about everything! The black and white threads create a pretty light gray color that you really can pair with mostly anything. The functionality of this piece sold me on it, and the knitting on the back was even prettier than the front.
It's hard to see here, but the pattern is in a fan shape. Really nice. Kept!
I never thought that I would buy all five items on the first try. I was honestly hoping to like at least one thing so that I didn't feel as though I'd wasted $20. The prices are higher than I normally pay, but the quality seems far better than what Target and Old Navy sell. Time will tell how the garments hold up, but upon first impression I think they are in line with Eddie Bauer quality and, as I used to work there, Brian and I have a lot of Eddie Bauer clothes. That stuff lasts nearly forever.
As if having your wardrobe put together for you and sent directly to you isn't enough, Stitch Fix also provides a style card for each item sent. These cards provide inspiration to create even more outfits when you pair their items with items that are already in your closet. Tan blazer and navy tank? Got 'em! Can't wait to wear them with my new pink crop pants. Navy ankle pants? Why yes, I do have those and I'll try them with both my new striped tee and my new plaid top.
So what's my verdict on Stitch Fix? I think it's obvious that I love it! I even sent an email to Stitch Fix to let them know how satisfied this brand new customer is. I told them I was really impressed with my stylist's efforts and felt that she truly took the time to read my requests and look through my Pinterest board. I added that I couldn't thank her enough and hoped that they would as her employer. She really nailed it, so I requested her as my stylist going forward. Well done, Catie.
Also, I had a blast creating a Pinterest board and mindfully exploring my style preferences. Sending a present to yourself is really a lovely thing to do, by the way. You deserve it! :) My total with taxes was $211.20 (two days of substitute teaching), and I feel it was worth it. By comparison, every dress I tried on at the mall was at least $100. Now I have five versatile pieces that, as far as I know, no one else around here has, and I can create quite a few stylish outfits. I really do hope this first Fix wasn't a fluke. My next one is scheduled to arrive on March 21st, so stay tuned.
If you are interested in trying it yourself, please use my referral link.








